Duane Bonifer  |   Published October 09, 2017

Judgment Day

Seventh-Annual Moot Court Competition
  • Hadley Smithhisler ’20 was named Top Advocate in the 2017 Moot Court. She is joined by finals judges, from left, Monmouth Dean of the Faculty David Timmerman, Justice David Vancil, chief judge of Illinois’ Ninth Judicial Circuit, and Monmouth Political Science Professor Andre Audette.
MONMOUTH, Ill. – For Monmouth College student Hadley Smithhisler ’20, participating in the College’s seventh-annual Moot Court competition helped confirm her career aspirations.

Smithhisler took part in the academic event for the first time this year, and she was named Top Advocate. That should give the sophomore a boost of confidence as she works toward attending law school after she graduates from Monmouth.

Smithhisler was one of 13 Monmouth students who participated in the College’s seventh-annual Moot Court competition. The preliminary round was held Oct. 7. Four students advanced to the final round, held Oct. 9 in the Morgan Room of Poling Hall.

The students argued the case: Is it unconstitutional to require voters to show a photo identification card in order to be able to vote?

Smithhisler, who argued that a voter ID law is unconstitutional, said “what fascinated me the most was how you can see things from both sides,”

“It was cool to see how you could attack this issue from all sides,” said Smithhisler, who is from Valley City, N.D.

Smithhisler said she “learned a lot” from Saturday’s preliminary round.

“After the first round on Saturday, I learned a lot of the things I had done wrong, the things I had missed, and the things that I hadn’t considered,” she said. “So it was a cool to be able to address that in the final round and improve my argument.

Participating in Moot Court has also helped Mackenzi Lafferty ’19 decide to pursue a career in law.

Lafferty was named Top Advocate in 2015, and she also advanced to the final round in 2016.

“It’s definitely made me more confident in my goal to attend law school, and it’s made me even more excited to be an attorney,” said Lafferty, who is from Canton, Ill. “I am actually very interested in voter ID laws, so I thought it was very fascinating. It’s also one of the topics I’m considering for my senior research next year, so I was really excited to study it.”

Joe Doner ’21 also competed in Moot Court for the first time. Doner, who is from Arlington Heights, Ill., also wants to be a lawyer after he graduates from Monmouth.

Doner said that although he didn’t agree with the position he argued in the finals – in favor the voter ID law – he learned a lot by participating in the process.

“I had a really hard time arguing for the side I didn’t believe in, but it was interesting to learn more about the thought process behind implementing voter ID laws,” he said. “Before this I thought, ‘There really isn’t a good reason.’ But there are a couple decent reasons for implementing laws like this. There are probably just ways of doing it rather than how it was suggested in this case.”

For finalist Samuil Georgiev, participating in Moot Court was a way to learn more about the U.S. legal system.

Georgiev is studying this fall at Monmouth before heading back to Pernik, Bulgaria.

“I’ve always been interested in law, and I’ve been considering the option of applying to law school after I graduate back in Bulgaria. So this was an opportunity for me to learn more about law and see how it actually works,” he said.

Georgiev said that participating in Moot Court also made a great semester at Monmouth even better.

“I’m having a great experience here, and this competition was part of the greatness of this experience,” he said.

The preliminary round’s judges were: Dan Cotter ’88, Kate Fitzsimmons Cross ’08, Brad Nahrstadt ’89, and Debra Nahrstadt.

The judges for the final round were: Andre Audette, Monmouth assistant professor political science; David Timmerman, dean of the Monmouth faculty; and Justice David Vancil, chief judge of Illinois’ Ninth Judicial Circuit.
Back to News & Events

Did you know?

  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College offers several international trips each year during 2-week Scots Terms in January and May. Recently students have traveled to Botswana, Greece, Scotland, Japan, and more. </p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_urls"><a href="https://monmouthcollege.edu/offices/global-engagement/" target="_blank">Scots Term</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College offers unique academic minors in Global Public Health and Global Food Security for students who want to use their education to address global challenges. </p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/global-public-health/" target="_blank">Global Public Health</a></li><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/global-food-security/" target="_blank">Global Food Security</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College has an active Pipe & Drum Band. Each year on Scholar’s Day in April the bagpipers wake students up at 6:00 a.m. by playing in the residence halls!</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/music/pipe-band/" target="_blank">Pipe Band</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p><strong>Monmouth College is the birthplace of the women’s fraternity movement. Pi Beta Phi, the first such collegiate women’s organization, was founded at Monmouth in 1867. It was followed three years later by Kappa Kappa Gamma. The two pioneering organizations today boast a total of 275 active chapters nationwide.</strong></p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/student-life/sororities-fraternities/" target="_blank">Sororities & Fraternities</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> We offer a certified Peace Corps Preparation program that gives Peace Corps bound graduates a leg up in the application process.</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/peace-corps-prep/" target="_blank">Peace Corps Prep</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> While we have the Wells Theater on campus, the Theatre department also uses the block-box auditorium Fusion Theatre downtown Monmouth.</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/theatre/" target="_blank">Theatre</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College is proudly test optional. Applicants may choose whether or to submit SAT or ACT scores for admission and scholarship consideration. </p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/admission/apply/test-optional/" target="_blank">Test Optional</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> 98% of Monmouth graduates were employed or enrolled in graduate school within six months of graduation.</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/wackerle-center/career-services/" target="_blank">Career Services</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> 99% of Monmouth students received some type of scholarship or financial assistance.</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/offices/student-financial-planning/types-of-aid/scholarships/" target="_blank">Scholarships</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> We’re no stranger to winning. Last year the Fighting Scots won Midwest Conference championships in Football, Women’s Soccer, Women’s Basketball and Men’s Track and Field. </p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_urls"><a href="https://monmouthscots.com/" target="_blank">Fighting Scots</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College covers the cost for all current students to get a U.S. passport. Unlock access to over 198 different countries! We’ll even help with the paperwork :)</p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_page"><a href="/academics/study-abroad/" target="_blank">Study Abroad</a></li></ul></div></aside>
  • <aside class="factoid-item"><div class="factoid-item-text"><p> Monmouth College has an educational garden and 6.7 acre farm. Students grow and harvest fruits and vegetables to sell at the local farmer’s market. </p></div><div class="factoid-item-links"><ul><li class="lw_related_urls"><a href="https://monmouthcollege.edu/academics/only-at-monmouth/educational-garden-farm/" target="_blank">Garden & Farm</a></li></ul></div></aside>